How To Choose The Best Roof To Put On Your House

Allstate Exteriors • October 26, 2020

The roof is perhaps the most important component of your home. It protects your property, family, and everything inside from the elements. With so many options for your new roof, you may not be sure if you should stick with your current roofing material or try something new. When choosing a new roof, there are several benefits you should consider, including the lifespan, energy efficiency, fire and wind resistance, and level of maintenance required. In general, here are the three most common roofing materials for Central Ohio residents.

1. Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles make up more than 75 percent of single-family homes in the US, and for good reasons. They are affordable and come in a variety of attractive styles and colors. Asphalt shingles also perform well in protecting homes from the elements.

Pros of Asphalt Shingles

  • Looks aesthetic on most styles of homes
  • Affordable
  • Last around 20 years on homes located in moderate climates
  • A broad selection of styles and colors
  • No support beyond regular roof sheathing is required
  • 3-tab shingles offer up to 60-70 MPH wind uplift, while high-wind shingles offer 130 MPH wind uplift
  • Shingle repair is easy and cost-effective

Cons of Asphalt Shingles

  • The lifetime cost is higher than tile, metal, or slate
  • Cheaper asphalt shingles last just 10-15 years, especially in hot, sunny climates
  • Rapid temperature fluctuations can cause asphalt shingles to crack
  • A poorly vented attic may trap heat and significantly shorten the lifespan of asphalt shingles
  • Asphalt shingles are the least eco-friendly roofing option
  • Mold or algae growth can be a problem on shingles in shady areas

2. Metal Roofing

Metal roofs may last as long as 100 years. Due to the continuous demand for durability, metal roofs have enjoyed a recent resurgence in the roofing industry. Although metal roofing materials are still manufactured in rolls, you can find rigid sheet roofing designs with vertical seam panels or modular press-formed panels which can be coated or painted with granules. The manufacturing processes for metal roofing systems allow for a variety of appearance options, including designs made to mimic shingles, tile, or wood shakes. The most common metals used are zinc, aluminum, and lightweight steel.

Pros of Metal Roofs

  • New styles can mimic shingles, tile, wood shakes, or slate
  • Available in dozens of colors 
  • Metal roofs last between 50 to 75 years, with warranties of 30-50 years
  • Metal reflects solar radiant heat, keeping your home cool and energy efficient in hot weather
  • Many metal roofing profiles have a Class A fire rating
  • Metal sheds snow and rain better than most other roofing materials
  • Metal roofs are recyclable
  • Lightweight and highly resistant to impact

Cons of Metal Roofs

  • More expensive than asphalt shingles and wood shakes
  • Without proper attic space or substrate , metal roofs can be noisier than other materials when it rains
  • Metal can dent when hit by heavy objects

3. Flat Roofs

When it comes to flat roofing systems, your options can be both limited and expansive. The most common materials for residential flat roofs include single-ply and modified bitumen. Since flat roofs typically have a very low slope, your main goal should be to create a barrier which will be impenetrable to water.


Flat roofs often require the application of adhesives, but other types like modified bitumen can be installed with a torch. Modified Bitumen is often installed in multiple layers, each being torched to the underlying surface. The installation process can be labor-intensive and should only be done by experienced professionals. You can also opt for cold-roll applications involving the application of roofing tar.


PVC Single-Ply Membrane is arguably the most popular type of flat roofing material. This flat roofing material is extremely strong and durable, offering a breaking point of 300 pounds per inch. PVC seams are hot-air welded (heat-welded) to create a watertight bond. The welded seams are typically stronger than the roofing material itself.

Pros of Flat Roofs

  • Modified Bitumen has multiple layers, making it relatively durable
  • PVC membranes, especially light-colored ones, are extremely energy efficient
  • Versatile since you can turn your rooftop into a garden or living area
  • Easy to maintain than steep-sloped roofs
  • Offers better energy efficiency, especially in warmer climates

Cons of Flat Roofs

  • Single-ply roofing membranes can be ripped apart by sharp objects and collisions
  • Poses challenges in colder climates since ice and snow can quickly pile up
  • Flat roofs will require replacement in 10-20 years

So, deciding on the best roofing system to install on your home will depend on your preference, budget, and climate. It’s recommended to speak with a reputable, local roofer to examine your exact situation and recommend the right roofing material. Allstate Exteriors in Central Ohio can help you choose the best material and style for your home. Contact us today to begin the conversation with one of our experienced roofing consultants.

Blue two-story house with white trim, front porch, and green lawn under a bright sky

Roof, Siding, And Gutter Repair Order: What To Fix First After A Storm

August 18, 2026
Storm damage can affect the roof, siding, and gutters at once. Learn the right repair order, when bundling makes sense, and what to verify first.
Three people review roofing estimates at a table with brochures, a laptop, and a coffee mug.

Insurance Adjuster Meeting Checklist For Roof Damage Claims

August 11, 2026
Prepare for a roof insurance adjuster meeting with the right photos, inspection report, claim details, questions, and follow-up steps.
Worker painting trim on a brick house exterior using a ladder

Roof Inspection Report Example: How To Read The Photos And Notes

August 4, 2026
Learn what a strong roof inspection report includes, from photo evidence and condition notes to repair reasoning, insurance documentation, and estimate handoff.
Workers installing black shingles on a steep roof under a blue sky

Cape Coral Tile Roof Underlayment: The Layer That Fails Before The Tile

July 28, 2026
Tile roofs in Cape Coral can look sound while underlayment problems develop below. Learn signs, inspection points, repair factors, and what to ask.
Worker repairing gray shingle roof with hammer on a house under a cloudy sky

Ohio Roof Hail Damage: What to Photograph Before You Call Insurance

July 21, 2026
A practical photo guide for Ohio homeowners after roof hail damage, including what to capture, how to organize it, and when to schedule an inspection.

Expert Roofing in Cape Coral, FL: Protecting Homes One Roof at a Time

April 29, 2026
When you live in a place as beautiful and storm prone as Cape Coral, FL , your roof isn’t just another part of the house. It’s your first and most vital line of defense against Florida’s blazing sun, high humidity, and hurricane season downpours. That’s why finding a dependable roofing contractor who knows the local weather, building codes, and roofing needs is more than just smart, it’s essential. Here at Allstate Exteriors , we’ve been proud to provide professional roofing in Cape Coral, FL , delivering high performance results to homeowners throughout neighborhoods like Pelican, Cape Harbour, Trafalgar, and Burnt Store. Our mission is simple: protect homes with expert craftsmanship, premium materials, and trustworthy service . Why Roofing in Cape Coral Requires Specialized Expertise Cape Coral isn’t just another Florida city, it’s a unique community with specific architectural styles, salt air exposure from the Gulf, and frequent tropical weather patterns. The roofs here aren’t just sloped pieces of protection, they’re carefully engineered systems that must withstand intense environmental pressure year after year. When we take on a roofing job in Cape Coral , we bring not only our tools and materials, but also a deep understanding of: Wind uplift ratings necessary for hurricane protection Reflective materials to reduce cooling costs during brutal Florida summers Ventilation solutions to combat moisture and mold Local permit and code requirements specific to Cape Coral and Lee County Whether it’s replacing an old asphalt shingle roof in the Yacht Club area or upgrading to a standing seam metal roof near Surfside Boulevard, we tailor each project for long term durability and local conditions. Real Results: Recent Roofing Projects in Cape Coral We’ve recently completed several roofing projects in Cape Coral that highlight the scope of our expertise and the quality we bring to each job. One standout job took place in the Rose Garden neighborhood. The homeowner reached out after repeated leaks from their 20-year-old tile roof. After a comprehensive inspection, we recommended a total tear off and reinstallation using high end barrel style clay tiles that match the home’s Mediterranean style. The result? Not only does the roof now provide superior water resistance and wind protection, but it also enhances the curb appeal of the entire property. You wouldn’t believe the transformation, and the homeowner couldn’t be happier. In another project over in Southwest Cape Coral near Cape Coral Parkway, we installed a modern metal roofing system for a homeowner looking to increase energy efficiency. Thanks to its reflective coating and seamless installation, the house now stays cooler in the summer and costs less to maintain. Our Roofing Services in Cape Coral, FL No two roofs and no two roofing clients are alike. That’s why we offer a wide variety of roofing services in Cape Coral , tailored for every need and budget: Roof Replacement – Is your roof past its prime? We’ll walk you through the best materials and options available, whether it's asphalt shingles, metal, tile, or flat roof systems. Roof Repair – From missing shingles to flashing failures and wind damage, our repairs are quick, thorough, and built to last. Roof Inspections – Whether you're buying a new home in Cape Coral or just want peace of mind, our inspections help identify potential problems before they become expensive headaches. Emergency Storm Repairs – When tropical weather strikes, we offer fast response service to secure your property and begin the restoration process. Every one of our jobs comes with clear communication, honest pricing, and a team of licensed, insured professionals committed to getting it right the first time.