The REAL Price Of A DIY Roof Replacement? Cost Analysis For The Frugal Homeowner:

Allstate Exteriors • April 17, 2023

Most homeowners are looking for ways to cut home improvements and repair costs. Doing some of the work yourself is a great way to save money, but you need to consider the actual costs when deciding which jobs to handle yourself and which are better left to the professionals.   

The Real Price of a Roof Replacement

Labor

Consider that you will need to schedule time off from work to install the roof. This time off also needs to be coordinated with others helping you. Some homeowners believe they can do the job alone but soon realize that carrying roof shingles up a ladder to the roof is very difficult to do alone. Homeowners often contact roofing contractors after they start an installation and then realize the project’s true scope.

Time to Completion

The time needed for a roof replacement needs to include preparation, installation, clean-up, waiting for construction permits, inspections, and other factors. All these can contribute to taking more time than expected to complete the installation. Inexperienced helpers also add to this equation.

Clean-up

After the job is complete, the clean-up begins. This clean-up involves removing all debris from the area, including landscaping near the home, driveway, and walkways. You will need a dumpster to haul everything away. Old roofing can be heavy. More than one person is needed to complete the clean-up process promptly.

Equipment Costs

Depending on the design of your roof, completing the job may require additional equipment. Extension ladders, scissors lifts, commercial nail guns, air compressors, shingle cutters, tarps in case of bad weather, Pry-bars, and other tools may be required to do the job correctly. Each helper will need tools. Renting these tools and equipment will drive up the overall cost.

Injury Risk

No one wants to think about this, but inexperienced roofers are unfamiliar with all the aspects of navigating a roof with different slopes and angles. Handling unfamiliar tools is also a risk. Your helpers may be family members or friends who are anxious to help you save on the cost of roof installation and disregard the possible dangers.

No Warranty

A warranty may not cover work done by a homeowner. This lack of coverage could wind up costing you over time. You may get a manufacturer’s warranty for defective materials, but nothing for poor workmanship. You will be responsible for the cost if significant repairs are necessary in the future.

Necessary Additional Repairs

A professional roofing company will do a complete inspection before starting the installation. During this careful examination of your roof, any damage to underlayment, structure, or other parts of your roof system will be uncovered and added to the time of completion and cost. It is difficult for a homeowner without extensive experience in roofing to spot these problems. A new roof installed over faulty decking or structure problems will certainly have a reduced lifespan and potentially need repairs. These repairs cannot be skipped, or problems will surface during the worst time, such as during a storm.

Additional Concerns

Like all construction projects, sometimes damage is discovered while doing a job. This damage needs to be repaired before continuing with installing the new roof. There may be bent or damaged flashing, gutters pulled away from the house, or damage to a chimney. Materials and extra time will be needed if this situation arises. Another problem that has become more common in recent years is lengthy delays in material delivery. These potential delays result in the need to coordinate a new time frame for the completion of the project. Hopefully, none of these problems will materialize, but you must be aware of the possibility.

The Bottom Line

Roof replacement involves all of these steps and more. The goal is to be aware of the scope of the construction before starting work to minimize frustration and estimate a realistic time frame for the completion of the project.

Saving money by thinking out of the box is commendable as long as you consider all these aspects of roof installation. Most homeowners realize the savings are far less than what was initially calculated in the budget. Additionally, a professional installation is a better solution to avoid the danger of injury to inexperienced family and friends recruited to assist with the construction. A professional roofing company will be able to help you install a quality roof safely. 

Please contact Allstate Exteriors to get a free estimate on a roof replacement. We have been proudly serving customers in Central Ohio and South West Florida since 2002. We aim to provide outstanding customer service and quality work on every job. Our friendly staff is always happy to answer any question regarding roof replacement or our services. We look forward to partnering with you for this roof replacement!

December 31, 2025
Your roof is more than just shingles and nails; it’s the primary shield for your home and everything inside it. When it comes time for a replacement, the estimate you receive is the roadmap for that entire project. At Allstate Exteriors, we believe that a transparent estimate is the foundation of a successful partnership. Unfortunately, not all estimates are created equal. Some are designed to win a job based on price alone, often hiding the "shortcuts" that lead to expensive repairs down the road. Here is how to ensure your roofing estimate is working for you, not against you. The Anatomy of a Quality Estimate A professional estimate should never leave you guessing. If a contractor hands you a single-page document with a total price and little else, that is a major red flag. A comprehensive bid should include: * Specific Materials: It shouldn't just say "shingles." It should list the brand, line (such as Owens Corning Duration Flex), and even the color. * The "Hidden" Components: A quality roof requires more than just shingles. Your estimate should detail the underlayment, ice and water shields, drip edges, and ventilation systems. * Labor and Disposal: Ensure the cost of tearing off the old roof and the fees for hauling away debris are explicitly stated. * Project Timeline: While weather can cause shifts, a professional roofer will provide estimated start and completion dates. Don't Skip the Paperwork Before you look at the bottom line, look at the credentials. In both Ohio and Florida, hiring an unlicensed or uninsured contractor puts the financial burden on you if an accident occurs. Always verify: 1. General Liability Insurance: Protects your property from accidental damage. 2. Workers’ Compensation: Ensures you aren't held liable if a crew member is injured on your property. 3. Manufacturer Certifications: Contractors with elite status, like Platinum Preferred status, can often offer extended warranties that standard installers cannot. The Danger of the "Lowest Bid" It is tempting to choose the cheapest option, especially for a major investment. However, an abnormally low price usually means something is missing. Whether it's using "seconds" (defective materials), skipping the flashing updates, or hiring untrained labor, the initial savings often disappear when the roof fails prematurely. Your Peace of Mind Matters A reputable contractor will never pressure you to sign a contract on the spot. They will walk you through the financing options, explain the warranty terms, and answer every question until you feel confident. Is your current roofing estimate missing these details? Contact Allstate Exteriors, the name you can trust, today for a free and transparent second opinion. We’ll help you compare your quotes and ensure your home gets the protection it deserves.
October 22, 2025
Your home is likely your most significant investment, and the roof is its first line of defense. When it comes time for a replacement, the process often feels less like home improvement and more like a high-stakes gamble. With dozens of contractors promising "unbeatable prices" and "lightning-fast installs," how do you distinguish a true craftsman from a corner-cutter? At Allstate Exteriors, we believe an estimate should be more than just a number, it should be a roadmap. Over the years, we have seen homeowners save a few hundred dollars upfront only to spend thousands later fixing avoidable mistakes. If you want to protect your home and your wallet, you need to learn how to read between the lines. Here are the five critical red flags to watch for before you sign a contract. 1. The "One-Line" Estimate If a contractor hands you a piece of paper that simply says " Roof Replacement: $12,000," they aren't being efficient, they’re being vague. A professional estimate is a detailed inventory of the work to be performed. You deserve to see a breakdown that includes: Specific Materials: Brand names, shingle types, and quantities. Logistics: Costs for labor, tear-off, and debris disposal. The Details: Plans for ventilation, flashing updates, and underlayment. Why it matters: Without transparency, you have no way of knowing if the contractor is using premium materials or the cheapest products available. 2. The Missing Paperwork In the roofing industry, "trust me" isn't a valid business credential. Any reputable company will proactively provide proof of liability insurance and workers’ compensation. If a worker is injured on your property and the company isn't insured, that liability could fall on you. Furthermore, look for manufacturer certifications. At Allstate Exteriors, we are Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractors, a distinction held by less than 1% of roofers nationwide. This isn't just a badge; it’s a guarantee that we meet the highest industry standards for installation and safety.
October 21, 2025
Florida homeowners know their roofs take a beating year-round. Between scorching UV rays, high humidity, tropical storms, and salty coastal air, your roof faces some of the harshest conditions in the country. Over time, those elements can cause costly damage if not properly maintained. Below, our experts at Allstate Exteriors break down the most common roof problems in Florida homes — and more importantly, how to prevent them before they turn into bigger issues. 1. Heat and Sun Damage Florida roofs endure intense UV exposure almost every day. Over time, constant sunlight can cause shingles to crack, curl, and lose their granules, reducing their ability to protect your home. Signs of sun damage: Shingles look faded or brittle Granules collecting in your gutters Roof feels extremely hot to the touch Prevention tips: Choose UV-resistant roofing materials like Owens Corning Duration FLEX shingles or metal roofing Schedule annual roof inspections to spot deterioration early Apply reflective coatings to reduce surface temperature 2. Roof Leaks and Water Intrusion Heavy rain is part of life in Florida. When flashing, underlayment, or seals around vents and chimneys fail, water can find its way into your attic and walls. Signs of roof leaks: Ceiling stains or sagging drywall Musty odors or visible mold Water spots near vents or skylights Prevention tips: Have a professional inspection after every major storm Keep gutters clean to prevent water backup Repair cracked caulking or flashing as soon as it’s noticed 3. Wind and Hurricane Damage High winds during Florida’s storm season can lift shingles, tear off flashing, or even expose the roof deck. Once wind gets under your shingles, your roof’s waterproofing is compromised. Prevention tips: Install wind-rated shingles that meet Florida Building Code standards Ensure your roofing nails and fasteners meet manufacturer and code requirements Schedule a post-hurricane inspection with a licensed contractor 4. Mold, Mildew, and Algae Growth Florida’s humid climate creates a breeding ground for algae and mildew — especially on north-facing or shaded roofs. Those dark streaks you see? That’s roof algae, and it can shorten the lifespan of your shingles. Prevention tips: Choose algae-resistant shingles with copper or zinc granules Trim overhanging trees to increase sunlight and airflow Schedule regular roof cleanings (avoid pressure washing!) 5. Poor Installation or Cheap Materials Unfortunately, after every hurricane, “storm chasers” and unlicensed contractors flood into Florida offering cheap roof replacements. Poor workmanship and low-quality materials can lead to leaks, early failure, and voided warranties. Prevention tips: Hire a licensed Florida roofing contractor with strong reviews and credentials (BTW..Allstate Exteriors has a 4.9 rating with thousands of google reviews!) Ask about Owens Corning Platinum Preferred or other certified partnerships Verify warranties and get all details in writing 6. Failing Flashing and Sealants Flashing around chimneys, skylights, and vents is one of the first areas to fail in Florida’s heat. When sealants crack, leaks begin. Prevention tips: Inspect flashing every 6 months Re-seal with roofing-grade caulk or have it replaced if corroded Keep an eye on roof penetrations after every storm How to Prevent Roof Problems in Florida Year-Round The best way to protect your home — and your wallet — is proactive maintenance. Here’s what our Allstate Exteriors pros recommend: ✅ Schedule a professional roof inspection twice a year (spring + fall) ✅ Clean gutters and downspouts before hurricane season ✅ Trim branches and clear debris after storms ✅ Keep attic ventilation open to prevent trapped moisture ✅ Use impact-resistant materials for future replacements 🏡 Final Thoughts Florida’s unique climate demands extra care for your roof — but prevention always costs less than repair. With routine maintenance, quality materials, and an experienced contractor, you can extend your roof’s life for decades. If you’re in Cape Coral, Orlando, or Palm Bay, the Allstate Exteriors Florida team is here to help. We’re Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractors (top 1% nationwide) and proud to keep Florida homes protected from the elements.
October 20, 2025
After a storm hits, it’s natural to glance up at your roof and wonder — “Did that do any real damage, or is it just aging?” It’s a question our team at Allstate Exteriors hears all the time. Knowing the difference between storm damage and normal wear and tear can determine whether you file an insurance claim or simply plan for future maintenance. Let’s break it down clearly - 💡 Quick Answer: Storm damage is sudden, unexpected, and caused by a specific event (like wind, hail, or falling debris). Wear and tear happens gradually over time from everyday exposure to sun, rain, and temperature changes. If your roof’s condition changed overnight after severe weather — that’s storm damage. If it’s slowly deteriorated over years — that’s normal aging. What Counts as Storm Damage? The Telltale Signs of Storm-Related Roof Damage Storm damage is typically sudden and uneven, meaning it affects certain areas more than others. Here’s what we look for during an inspection: Missing or lifted shingles: High winds can break the seal and tear shingles completely off. Granule loss in random patches: Hail impact can knock granules loose, leaving dark or bare spots. Cracked or bruised shingles: Hail can bruise asphalt shingles, making them soft or pitted. Dented flashing, vents, or gutters: Clear sign of hail or debris impact. Leaks appearing shortly after a storm: Water intrusion from wind-driven rain or torn shingles. These types of damage can compromise your roof’s protective layers, even if they’re not immediately visible from the ground. Pro Tip: Always document storm damage with photos and schedule a professional inspection before filing an insurance claim — insurers often require proof tied to a specific weather event. What’s Considered Normal Wear and Tear? How Aging Naturally Affects Your Roof Even the best roofs age. Exposure to the sun, seasonal temperature swings, and years of wind and rain gradually cause minor changes that are not covered by insurance. Common examples include: Faded shingle color or surface granule loss Small cracks or curling edges from UV exposure Moss or algae growth Nail pops or minor sealant wear around flashing Slight sagging from years of weight and moisture cycles These are maintenance issues, not sudden damage — and while they can lead to bigger problems down the road, they typically signal it’s time for upkeep or eventual replacement, not a claim. Why the Difference Matters Insurance Coverage Depends on the Cause Insurance companies only cover sudden, accidental events — meaning storm damage. Normal wear and tear falls under homeowner responsibility. That’s why accurate documentation and professional evaluation matter so much. At Allstate Exteriors, our trained inspectors know exactly how to tell the difference. We’ll identify: The age of the damage (fresh vs. old) The pattern of impact (random vs. consistent) Whether the issue was caused by wind, hail, or improper installation That distinction could be the difference between an approved claim or an out-of-pocket repair. Local Conditions in Ohio & Florida Weather Patterns That Affect Roofs Differently Ohio: Hail, heavy snow, and freeze-thaw cycles cause shingle cracking and granule loss. Florida: High winds, hurricanes, and salt air break down sealants and lift shingles faster. Knowing your local climate risks helps you spot the difference between long-term wear and true storm damage. The Bottom Line: Storm damage happens fast and usually leaves visible clues. Normal wear and tear creeps in over time. Either way, ignoring changes can shorten your roof’s life and void your manufacturer’s warranty. When in doubt, call the pros. One free inspection from Allstate Exteriors can tell you exactly what’s going on — no guessing, no pressure. Schedule Your Free Storm Damage Inspection
October 17, 2025
When most people think about their roof, they don’t usually think about their gutters. But truth is — your gutters are one of the hardest working parts of your home’s exterior. They may not be the most glamorous feature, but they play a major role in keeping your roof, siding, and foundation safe from costly water damage. At Allstate Exteriors, we’ve seen firsthand what happens when gutters are clogged, damaged, or missing altogether — and it’s never pretty. So, let’s break down why gutters are so important and what their purpose really is. What Do Gutters Actually Do? Gutters are designed to channel rainwater away from your home. When rain hits your roof, it flows down to the edge. Without gutters, that water would pour directly off your roof and pool around your foundation, seep into your siding, or wash away landscaping. Properly installed gutters: Collect rainwater running off your roof Direct it into downspouts Carry that water safely away from your home’s base That simple process helps protect nearly every major part of your home — from the roof deck to the basement. Why Gutters Are So Important Here’s what happens when your gutters are doing their job (and what can go wrong when they’re not). 1. They Protect Your Roof and Fascia Gutters help keep water from backing up under your shingles. When debris builds up and clogs your gutters, water can overflow and soak into the fascia board (the area right under your roofline). Over time, that causes rot and can even lead to roof leaks. 2. They Prevent Foundation Damage Pooling water around your home’s base is one of the biggest causes of foundation cracks and settling. Gutters move that water away before it can soak into the ground near your foundation. This is especially important here in Ohio and Florida , where heavy rain can come down fast and flood-prone areas are common. 3. They Protect Siding and Windows Without gutters, rainwater running off the roof can streak down your siding and windows, leading to stains, wood rot, and even interior water leaks. Gutters prevent that by controlling where the water goes — and keeping it away from your walls. 4. They Help Prevent Soil Erosion and Landscape Damage Ever notice dirt splashing up on your home after a heavy rain? That’s from water falling straight off the roof. Over time, this erodes soil and destroys mulch, grass, or flower beds. Gutters and downspouts control the flow of water so your landscaping stays beautiful. 5. They Reduce Mold and Mildew Growth When water constantly sits near your home, it creates the perfect environment for mold and mildew. Proper drainage prevents that moisture buildup and keeps your home cleaner and healthier. Signs Your Gutters Might Need Attention Not sure if your gutters are still doing their job? Here are a few red flags to watch for: Water spilling over the sides during rain Peeling paint or rot on your fascia or soffit Sagging or pulling gutters Puddles forming near your foundation Cracks in your foundation or basement walls Rust or visible holes in gutter sections If you spot any of these, it’s time for a gutter repair or gutter replacement before it leads to more serious damage. Gutter Systems That Work Best At Allstate Exteriors, we install durable, seamless gutter systems designed to handle the heaviest rain - perfect for Ohio storms and Florida downpours . Seamless gutters not only look cleaner, but they also reduce leaks compared to traditional sectional systems. We also recommend gutter guards, especially if your home is surrounded by trees. Gutter guards help keep leaves and debris out, meaning less maintenance and fewer chances for clogs. The Bottom Line Gutters are more than just metal strips along your roofline - they’re your home’s built-in drainage system. Without them, your home would be constantly fighting against the damage caused by water. Whether you need new gutters installed, old ones replaced, or just want to make sure yours are ready for the next storm, Allstate Exteriors is here to help. Our team provides honest assessments, top-quality materials, and expert installation every time. Ready to Schedule a Gutter Inspection? If you’ve noticed water overflowing, sagging gutters, or just want peace of mind before the next big rain, we’ve got you covered .
October 16, 2025
By Allstate Exteriors – Your Local Roofing Experts When winter hits Columbus, your roof takes on the full force of snow, ice, and freezing rain. If your roof isn’t ready, small problems can quickly turn into leaks, water damage, or costly repairs. Taking a few simple steps now can protect your home all season long. 1. Schedule a Roof Inspection Before the cold weather arrives, schedule a professional roof inspection in Columbus, Ohio . At Allstate Exteriors, our experts check for: Missing or cracked shingles Soft or damaged decking Loose flashing or exposed nail heads Signs of leaks or water intrusion Fixing these issues early helps your roof last longer and keeps your home safe through the winter. 2. Clean Your Gutters and Downspouts Leaves and debris in your gutters can block water flow. When snow melts, this can cause ice dams — one of the biggest winter roofing problems in Ohio. ✅ Clear gutters before the first freeze ✅ Make sure downspouts are open and draining properly ✅ Consider adding gutter guards for long-term protection 3. Trim Back Tree Branches Branches that hang over your roof can snap under the weight of snow or ice. Trimming them now prevents damage to your shingles and gutters later. 4. Check Attic Insulation and Ventilation A warm attic can melt snow on your roof, which then refreezes at the edges and forms ice dams. Good ventilation and insulation help keep attic temperatures even — protecting your roof and lowering energy costs. If you’re not sure what condition your attic is in, Allstate Exteriors can inspect it for you. 5. Seal Flashing and Roof Penetrations Water often sneaks in around chimneys, vents, and skylights. Before winter, check the sealant and flashing around these areas. Resealing them now prevents leaks when temperatures start to fluctuate. 6. Watch for Flat or Low-Slope Roofs If your home or garage has a flat or low-slope roof, make sure drains are clear and no areas are sagging. Heavy snow can cause ponding water, leaks, or even collapse if not maintained properly. Stay Protected All Winter Long Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against Ohio’s winter weather. At Allstate Exteriors, we’ve helped homeowners in Columbus and throughout Central Ohio stay protected for over 20 years. As an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor with an A+ BBB rating , we take pride in doing things the right way — every time. SCHEDULE YOUR FREE ESTIMATE!