Tips to Help You Pick the Best Shingle Color for Your Home
May 21, 2025
Selecting the perfect shingle color for your home is more than just an aesthetic choice—it can impact energy efficiency, resale value, and even how well your roof holds up over time. Your roof is one of the most prominent features of your home, and its color significantly contributes to the overall curb appeal. Choosing the right shade can enhance architectural features, create a welcoming ambiance, and even influence temperature regulation inside your house. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to decide on the best one. If you're a homeowner in Columbus, Ohio,
working with a trusted roofing contractor can make all the difference in ensuring that your choice complements your home and suits the local climate. A well-informed decision will not only improve your home’s appearance but also increase its value and efficiency. Understanding the factors that go into selecting the right shingle color will help you make a confident choice that enhances your home's exterior for years to come.
Why Shingle Color Matters
Choosing the right shingle color is about more than just curb appeal—it plays a critical role in various aspects of your home’s performance and longevity. The right color selection can affect everything from energy costs to maintenance efforts, making it an essential decision rather than just an aesthetic one. Here’s why it’s important:
- Energy Efficiency – Light-colored shingles reflect sunlight and can help keep your home cooler, while dark shingles absorb heat, which can be beneficial in colder months.
- Resale Value – The right color can increase your home’s appeal to potential buyers, making it easier to sell.
- Weather Resistance – Some colors may show dirt, algae, or wear more than others, which can affect maintenance requirements.
- Aesthetic Harmony – Your shingle color should complement your home’s siding, trim, and overall design for a balanced look.
Factors You Should Consider When Choosing a Shingle Color
Before committing to a shingle color, it’s important to evaluate various factors to ensure your choice is both functional and visually appealing. Taking the time to analyze these key elements will help you select a color that enhances your home’s curb appeal and meets practical requirements. A well-chosen shingle color can make your home feel more inviting, contribute to its overall aesthetic, and even impact long-term maintenance needs. Here are the most important factors to consider:
- Architectural Style of Your Home – Certain roof colors pair better with specific architectural styles. For example, Mediterranean-style homes look stunning with terracotta or brownish shingles, while modern homes may benefit from sleek gray or black shingles.
- Exterior Colors and Materials – Your home’s siding, brick, stucco, or stone should complement the shingle color to create a cohesive look.
- Climate Considerations – Some homeowners experience both warm summers and cold winters. Lighter shingles reflect heat and help keep your home cooler, while darker shingles absorb heat, which may be beneficial in winter.
- Neighborhood Aesthetics and HOA Guidelines – Choosing a color that blends well with surrounding homes can enhance curb appeal and maintain consistency, especially if you have a homeowner association (HOA) with specific rules.
- Long-Term Maintenance and Durability – Darker shingles may show dirt and wear more noticeably over time, whereas lighter shades can better hide imperfections.
Popular Shingle Colors and Their Effects on Your Home
The color of your shingles plays a significant role in the overall look and performance of your home. It’s not just about style—your choice of shingle color can influence energy efficiency, curb appeal, and even your home’s resale value. The right color can enhance your home’s architecture, complement its exterior materials, and create a cohesive, polished look. Here are some popular options and their effects:
- Black and Dark Gray – A classic, sophisticated choice that pairs well with almost any exterior. However, dark shingles absorb more heat, which could lead to higher cooling costs in the summer.
- Brown and Earth Tones – Ideal for traditional and rustic-style homes, these colors blend well with natural surroundings.
- Gray and Blue Tones – Give a sleek and contemporary appearance, complementing homes with stone or metal elements.
- Green and Other Unique Colors – Great for homes with a distinct personality but should be carefully matched with siding and trim to avoid clashing.
Common Shingle Colors to Avoid
While many shingle colors can enhance your home’s look, some may be less desirable due to maintenance concerns or aesthetic limitations. Certain colors may also fade faster due to sun exposure, leading to an uneven, worn-out appearance over time. Additionally, some colors may not complement your neighborhood’s overall aesthetic, potentially affecting curb appeal and even property value. When selecting a color, it's crucial to think long-term—what looks trendy today may not age well in the next decade. Avoiding colors that highlight dirt, algae, or discoloration can also save you time and effort in maintenance.
- Overly Bright or Unusual Colors – Bright reds, oranges, or purples may clash with most home styles and reduce resale value.
- Mismatched Tones – A color that doesn’t blend well with your home’s siding or brick can create an unappealing contrast.
- White or Very Light Shingles – While they reflect heat well, these shingles may show dirt, stains, and algae growth more than darker colors.
- Very Dark Brown or Black in Hot Climates – Although these colors look sleek, they can absorb too much heat, leading to higher cooling costs in warmer months.
Tools That Can Help You Choose the Right Shingle Color
Thanks to modern technology, you don’t have to guess how a certain shingle color will look on your home. Many homeowners struggle with visualizing how different shingle colors will complement their siding, trim, and overall exterior. Fortunately, various tools and resources are available to take the guesswork out of the process. Virtual visualizers allow you to upload a photo of your home and try out different shingle colors in real-time, helping you see how each option blends with your exterior. Consulting with a professional roofing contractor can also provide expert insight, ensuring that your choice not only looks great but also meets practical needs such as energy efficiency and durability. By using these tools, you can confidently select a shingle color that enhances your home’s aesthetic appeal and long-term performance. Here are a few tools that can help:
- GAF Virtual Remodeler – Upload a photo of your home and try different shingle colors to see what fits best.
- Owens Corning Roofing Color Compass – Helps homeowners explore color combinations and find the best match based on their preferences.
- Consulting a Professional Roofing Contractor – A roofing contractor, like Allstate Exteriors, can offer personalized recommendations based on your home’s architecture and the local climate.
Frequently Asked Questions About Shingle Colors
What is the most popular shingle color?
Black, gray, and brown shingles are among the most popular choices because they offer timeless appeal and work well with most home styles.
Do darker shingles make a house hotter?
Yes, dark-colored shingles absorb more heat, which can increase indoor temperatures during the summer. However, proper ventilation and insulation can help mitigate this effect.
Will a lighter or darker shingle last longer?
Both can last equally long, provided they are high-quality and professionally installed. However, darker shingles may show wear and tear more visibly over time.
How can I tell if my HOA has rules about shingle colors?
Check your HOA’s bylaws or contact your association directly before making a final decision to ensure your choice aligns with any community guidelines.
Can I change my shingle color later if I don’t like it?
While possible, replacing shingles can be costly. That’s why it’s essential to choose wisely the first time, using visualizer tools and professional advice.
Make an Informed Choice for a Roof That Stands Out
Selecting the right shingle color is a balance between aesthetics, functionality, and durability. By considering factors such as climate, home style, and HOA regulations, you can make a decision that enhances curb appeal and longevity. If you're unsure, consulting a trusted roofing contractor like Allstate Exteriors can help guide you toward the perfect choice for your home.
For expert advice and high-quality roofing services, visit our Residential Roof Replacements
page to learn more!

It’s easy to brush off a small roof leak. Maybe you noticed a faint water stain on the ceiling, a tiny drip during heavy rain, or some shingles that look out of place. You tell yourself, “It’s not that bad. I’ll deal with it later.” But here’s the truth: even the smallest roof leaks can snowball into major and expensive problems. At Allstate Exteriors, we’ve seen homeowners put off minor roof repairs only to face mold, rotten decking, and even structural damage down the road. If you’re wondering what really happens when you ignore a small roof leak, let’s break it down. 1. Water Damage Spreads Quickly Even a small leak allows water to creep into your attic, insulation, and drywall. Over time, that moisture soaks into wood, weakens materials, and spreads throughout your home. Rotting wood decking can compromise your roof’s structural integrity. Stained ceilings and walls lower your home’s curb appeal and value. Sagging drywall can lead to costly interior repairs. 2. Mold and Mildew Growth Where there’s moisture, mold is never far behind. A small leak creates the perfect environment for mold and mildew to grow inside your attic and walls. Mold spores can spread throughout your HVAC system. It can trigger allergies and respiratory issues for your family. Once mold sets in, remediation can cost thousands of dollars. 3. Higher Energy Bills A leaky roof doesn’t just let water in—it lets air out. Moisture damages insulation, making your home less energy-efficient. That means your AC or furnace has to work harder, and your utility bills creep up every month. Replacing insulation and fixing leaks later will cost far more than a simple repair today. 4. Structural Damage to Your Home If leaks continue unchecked, the consequences can be severe: Roof decking may collapse under pressure. Support beams can weaken, affecting your entire home’s stability. Water may even reach your foundation, causing cracks and shifting. What started as a “minor nuisance” could eventually compromise your home’s safety. 5. Shortened Roof Lifespan Your roof is designed to last 20–30 years or more, depending on the materials. But ignoring small leaks accelerates wear and tear. Moisture trapped beneath shingles or flashing will deteriorate roofing materials faster, often forcing homeowners into a full roof replacement years earlier than expected. 6. Insurance May Not Cover It Here’s a harsh reality: most insurance companies expect homeowners to handle routine maintenance. If you delay fixing a small roof leak, your insurance provider could deny your claim for damage, leaving you with the bill. Proactive repairs protect both your home and your wallet. How to Prevent Small Leaks From Becoming Big Problems At Allstate Exteriors, we recommend: Annual roof inspections to catch issues early. Storm damage checks after hurricanes, high winds, or hail. Prompt repairs for missing shingles, cracked flashing, or damaged gutters. Small roof leaks may not seem urgent, but the hidden damage they cause is real and often devastating. By acting quickly, you’ll protect your home, your family, and your investment. Call today to schedule your free estimate!

If you’ve ever gathered multiple roofing estimates, you’ve probably noticed something surprising: the numbers don’t always line up. One contractor might give you a low price, another comes in much higher, and the rest fall somewhere in between. So why do roofing estimates vary so much, and how can you make sure you’re comparing them fairly? At Allstate Exteriors & Restoration Services, we’ve been helping homeowners in Ohio and Florida replace and repair their roofs for decades. We know that your roof is one of the most important investments you’ll ever make for your home, and we believe you deserve clear, honest information when choosing a roofing contractor. Let’s break down the reasons estimates differ and what you should look for when reviewing them. 1. The Type and Quality of Roofing Materials One of the biggest factors in the price of a roof replacement is the type of roofing material. Not all shingles are created equal. For example: Three-tab shingles are typically the most affordable but also have the shortest lifespan. Architectural shingles cost more but are thicker, more durable, and add curb appeal. Impact-resistant shingles and premium options (like Owens Corning Duration FLEX) can provide enhanced protection against wind, hail, and severe weather. But it doesn’t stop at shingles. Quality underlayment, ice and water shield, flashing, vents, and even the type of nails used can all impact the total estimate. 👉 At Allstate Exteriors, we only use Owens Corning roofing products because they’re proven to withstand harsh weather while offering excellent warranties. Our detailed estimates include all the essentials so you’re not left with hidden costs down the road. 2. Labor Costs and Installation Standards Roofing isn’t just about materials - it’s about the people installing them. A roof can only perform as well as it’s installed. Contractors who invest in training, safety certifications, and skilled crews may charge more for labor, but the quality of the installation will save you money in the long run. Crews that are underpaid or rushed may cut corners, leading to leaks and premature roof failure. Certified roofing contractors follow strict manufacturer guidelines, ensuring your roof lasts as long as possible. 👉 As an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor, Allstate Exteriors is held to the highest installation standards in the industry. That means your roof is installed correctly the first time—giving you peace of mind for years to come. 3. Warranty Coverage Another reason roofing estimates vary is the type of warranty offered. Some companies only provide a basic one- or two-year workmanship guarantee. Others, especially certified contractors, can offer extended manufacturer-backed warranties that cover both materials and labor. 👉 Because of our Platinum Preferred status, Allstate Exteriors can offer extended Owens Corning warranties that most local contractors simply cannot. Pair that with our workmanship guarantee, and you’re covered from every angle. 4. The Scope of Work Not all estimates include the same level of detail. Some roofing contractors may only quote for shingle replacement, while others include additional work like: Replacing rotten decking Upgrading ventilation Installing new flashing around chimneys and skylights Removing and disposing of old materials 👉 At Allstate Exteriors, we provide clear, transparent estimates with line-by-line breakdowns, so you know exactly what’s included and what’s not. 5. Transparency and Reputation Sometimes the lowest bid isn’t really the best deal. Low-ball estimates may not include proper insurance, quality products, or experienced installers and that can cost you more in repairs later. When comparing estimates, always look beyond the price: Is the contractor licensed and insured? Do they have a proven reputation with 5-star reviews? Are they local and established, or could they disappear when you need warranty service? 👉 With thousands of satisfied customers, an A+ rating with the BBB, and countless 5-star reviews, Allstate Exteriors has built a reputation for doing things the right way. We’re a family-owned company that’s here to stay. How to Compare Roofing Estimates Fairly When you’re reviewing multiple bids, keep these steps in mind: Compare apples to apples. Make sure each estimate includes the same quality materials and scope of work. Ask questions. If something isn’t clear, ask the contractor to explain it. A good roofing company will be transparent. Consider long-term value. The cheapest roof may not last as long or provide the same level of protection as one installed by a certified contractor with premium materials. Frequently Asked Questions: Why is one roofing estimate so much lower than the others? It’s often because cheaper materials, limited warranties, or less experienced crews are being used. Always read the fine print. Should I always pick the lowest roofing estimate? Not necessarily. The lowest price may cost you more in repairs and replacements later. Look at the overall value, not just the number. How can I be sure my roofing estimate is fair? Work with a trusted, local roofing company with a solid reputation, certifications, and detailed proposals. At Allstate Exteriors, we believe homeowners deserve more than a number on a piece of paper. You deserve clarity, honesty, and peace of mind. That’s why we take the time to explain our estimates, show you exactly what’s included, and stand behind our work long after the project is complete. Contact Allstate Exteriors today to schedule your free estimate!

A strong storm can be unsettling. You hear the howling wind outside, watch the trees sway, and wonder if your home will hold up against Mother Nature’s power. Once the storm passes, most homeowners do the same thing: step outside, glance up at the roof, and breathe a sigh of relief when everything looks okay. But here’s the truth: what you see from the ground is only part of the story. Wind damage to your roof isn’t always obvious, and waiting until you spot a problem could mean costly repairs later. At Allstate Exteriors, we’ve inspected countless roofs in Ohio and Florida, and one of the most common phrases we hear is: “I thought my roof was fine—I didn’t see anything wrong!” Hidden wind damage is sneaky, but left unchecked, it can compromise your roof’s integrity and your home’s safety. How Wind Quietly Damages Your Roof When people picture wind damage, they usually imagine shingles flying off in big, dramatic chunks. While that can happen, wind often leaves behind subtle, invisible damage that isn’t easy to notice: Shingle Lifting – Even if shingles don’t blow off, strong gusts can loosen the adhesive seal. A lifted shingle might lay flat again, but the waterproof barrier is already broken. Granule Loss – The gritty texture on shingles protects your roof from sun and water. Wind rubs shingles against each other, knocking those protective granules loose—kind of like sandpaper wearing them down. Nail Stress – Wind pressure tugs on fasteners. Over time, it can weaken nails or pull them up slightly, creating hidden entry points for water. Moisture Intrusion – Once water finds even a hairline gap, it can seep into your roof’s underlayment and decking, quietly causing rot, mold, and stains that may not show up indoors for months. Why You Might Not Notice Damage Right Away Wind damage has a way of disguising itself. Here’s why so many homeowners overlook it: From the Ground, Everything Looks Fine – Unless shingles are curled, cracked, or missing, the roof might look completely intact. Symptoms Are Delayed – A roof leak doesn’t always happen the day after a storm. It might take weeks—or even a season—for damage to reveal itself inside. Rooflines Are Hard to See – On steep or tall roofs, the compromised areas are often out of sight. Think of it like a tiny crack in your car’s windshield—it may not seem like a big deal at first, but if left alone, it will spread and become a much bigger problem. The Cost of Ignoring Hidden Wind Damage Overlooking invisible damage can lead to much bigger headaches, such as: Costly Repairs Later – What could’ve been a quick repair may turn into replacing large sections of your roof. Insurance Claim Issues – Insurance companies may deny coverage if too much time passes before damage is documented. Interior Problems – Ceiling stains, peeling paint, mold, and insulation damage often trace back to wind-damaged shingles that looked “fine.” S hortened Roof Lifespan – A compromised roof simply won’t last as long, which means you’ll be replacing it sooner than expected. What Homeowners Should Do After a Windstorm You don’t need to climb up on your roof to check it yourself—in fact, it can be dangerous. Instead, follow these steps to protect your home: Schedule a Professional Roof Inspection – A certified roofing expert knows exactly what to look for and can spot issues the average homeowner would never notice. Keep Records – Write down the date of the storm, snap photos of your yard or siding if anything blew off, and save any news reports of wind speeds in your area. This helps if you ever need to file an insurance claim. Don’t Wait – Even if everything looks okay, time is critical. Acting quickly means repairs are easier, cheaper, and more likely to be covered by insurance. Protecting Your Home Starts with the Roof Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against the elements. It protects your family, your belongings, and the structure of your house itself. That’s why it’s so important not to trust a “quick glance” after a storm. At Allstate Exteriors, our trained professionals know how to spot wind damage that isn’t visible to the untrained eye. We’ll give you an honest assessment of your roof’s condition and recommend the best next steps - whether that’s a simple repair , maintenance, or a replacement. Call Allstate Exteriors today to schedule your free inspection.

When hurricanes or tropical storms move through Florida, the damage they leave behind can be overwhelming. Roofs often take the hardest hit—leaving families vulnerable to leaks, water intrusion, and unsafe living conditions. Thankfully, federal programs like FEMA’s Temporary Roofing Assistance can help bridge the gap between disaster and recovery. At Allstate Exteriors, we’ve worked with countless homeowners who needed immediate protection after a storm while planning their permanent roof repairs. Here’s what you should know about FEMA’s roofing assistance and how our team can help you through the process. What Is FEMA’s Roofing Assistance? FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency) provides temporary roofing assistance after a federally declared disaster. The most well-known program is the Blue Roof Program, which installs durable, weather-resistant coverings to shield damaged roofs from the elements. It’s important to note that FEMA’s program is a short-term solution—its goal is to make homes safe and habitable until a permanent repair or replacement can be completed by a trusted roofing company. Who Qualifies? To be eligible, you typically must: Live in a federally declared disaster area Have roof damage that makes your primary residence unsafe or unlivable Provide documentation of ownership and residency FEMA may send an inspector to confirm the extent of damage before approving assistance. What It Covers (and Doesn’t) ✅ Temporary coverings or limited repairs to protect against further water intrusion ✅ Materials and labor provided through authorized contractors ❌ Full roof replacements ❌ Cosmetic upgrades or non-essential improvements ❌ Detached structures (sheds, garages, etc.) Insurance vs. FEMA Assistance Many Florida homeowners wonder if they should contact FEMA or their insurance company first. The answer: always start with your insurance provider. FEMA is meant to step in when insurance coverage doesn’t cover immediate needs. At Allstate Exteriors, we help homeowners every day with insurance claims, inspections, and repairs to ensure they get the coverage and long-term solutions they deserve. How Allstate Exteriors Fits In While FEMA may cover temporary protection, our team steps in to deliver the permanent, high-quality repairs or replacements your home needs. As an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor with an A+ BBB rating, we’re trusted across Florida to: Perform detailed storm damage inspections (with photo and video documentation) Work directly with homeowners through the insurance process Install durable roofing systems built to withstand Florida’s climate We know that after a storm, homeowners need more than just a tarp—they need peace of mind. That’s why our crews are on call and ready to respond quickly when disaster strikes. Final Thoughts FEMA roofing assistance can provide valuable short-term relief, but it’s only part of the recovery process. Once your home is safe, turn to a trusted local contractor like Allstate Exteriors for the permanent repairs that protect your family long-term. Whether you’re dealing with minor damage or a full roof replacement, our Florida teams are here to help you every step of the way. 👉 Need a roof inspection after a storm? Contact Allstate Exteriors today for your free storm damage assessment.

When Hurricane Ian struck Florida, it became one of the most powerful storms to ever hit the state. Winds howled, rain pounded, and neighborhoods braced for impact. While many homes across the region suffered devastating damage, something incredible stood out to us at Allstate Exteriors: over 200 of our roofs stood strong through the storm. That’s not just luck—that’s the result of combining top-of-the-line materials with quality craftsmanship. The Power of Owens Corning TruDefinition® Duration Shingles When the storm put homes to the test, the roofs built with Owens Corning TruDefinition® Duration Shingles proved why they’re trusted nationwide. Designed with SureNail® Technology, these shingles lock in place with gripping power that can withstand hurricane-force winds. Their durability and design make them one of the toughest defenses a homeowner can have when storms roll in off the coast. But shingles alone don’t win the battle against a hurricane. Installation makes all the difference. Craftsmanship That Goes Beyond the Surface At Allstate Exteriors, we don’t cut corners. Every nail, every shingle, every seam is carefully placed with precision and care. Why? Because we know that when the weather turns dangerous, families are relying on us to keep them safe. When Hurricane Ian arrived, that dedication showed. Roof after roof we installed stayed intact, shielding homeowners from the worst of the storm. Over 200 homes protected—200 families with peace of mind. That’s what we call results. More Than a Roof: A Promise of Protection A roof is more than just a structure on top of your home—it’s protection, security, and peace of mind. It’s what lets families rest easy at night, even when the wind howls outside. Knowing that our work helped protect so many families during one of Florida’s worst hurricanes is exactly why we do what we do. Why Homeowners Trust Allstate Exteriors Choosing a roofing company isn’t just about finding someone who can “get the job done.” It’s about finding a partner you can trust with your home, your family, and your future. Homeowners choose us because: We’re an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor, a title less than 1% of roofers nationwide earn. We’re family-owned and operated, which means we treat every home like it’s our own. We’ve earned thousands of 5-star reviews from happy homeowners across Ohio and Florida. We’re A+ rated with the BBB, recognized for our integrity, reliability, and commitment to excellence. Ready to Protect Your Home Before the Next Storm? If you want a roof that can stand up to whatever nature throws at it, trust the company that has already helped hundreds of families weather the storm. 📞 Call Allstate Exteriors today for your free inspection . Let’s make sure your home is ready for the next season, no matter what comes your way.